Times are Tough – Enter the Consultant
For most businesses times are very tough and many of their management are entering an unknown and uncertain world. When this happens, management often call in the consultants. This can be for many reason – management need options, they don’t really know what to do and need help, or in some circumstances are looking for a “fall guy” if things dont improve. While consultants do have a place in helping management, they are not there to replace them. So what is the role of consultants during an economic downturn?
First i have to come clean. I spent just under 5 years with global management consultants McKinsey & Co in the late 90′s and do have a new consulting business, Classified Ad Ventures, that provides online classified businesses with advice and guidance on what to do next. That said … on with the discussion!
There are two types of consultants – those that are there to help management think through problems by bringing in specific expertise and those that are there to work with existing staff for a a specific project (e.g. customise SAP). My comments are really around the first group – the strategic and operational advisors to management.
Management walk a fine line when they use consultants. When used well, consultants can help a management team see clearly what they need to do. When not used well, they chew up time, resources, set unrealistic expectations and merely restate what the management team already knew – but in a neat story and with nice charts!
The best use of consultants usually involves a clear problem that needs solving, the problem being the most important to the business, and a management team that has knows what it wants to do and has the ability to do it. The consultants challenge the current thinking with a goal of delivering a more robust outcome. The consultants need to have strong subject matter expertise to make sure that the management team doesnt spend heaps of time bringing them up to speed.
However, uing consultants has downsides and often it is the downsides that eventuate. One downside is that consultants become a crutch for a business. The management team relies on them more than the internal team as they are the “experts”. It can get to the more ridiculous situation where management cant make a decision without consulting the consultants first – i have seen it!
Another downside is that once the consultants are in a business, management tend to rely on them rather than the team who are employed there. This can create a division and a perceived lack of trust between the management team and the empoyees. As the employees often have to implement the recommendaions of the consultants (if they get implemented), this can lead to “white anting” of a series of recommendations.
Another downside is that expectations are raised to unrealistic levels. The consultants present to the Board – either directly or indirectly – what a business could in theory do and the Board latches on to these opportunities and then starts to think that the management team should be able to achieve them. The problem is that most management teams that are good dont use consultants – they just get on with it.
A final downside with using consultants is that they are often very smart people who have strong logical minds but have not actually run a business of the size they are consulting to. They are passionate but not necessarily qualified in some of the things they are making recommendations on.
So when should you use consultants? That is clear – use them on specific projects that need some sort of change implemented that the current management just cant make happen. For examle, they can be used at the mid-manager level on projects such as cost reduction. The discipline they bring to the problem will help achieve greater results than if left internally.
They should also be used when management is entering unchartered waters and know that they are out of their depth. The consultants should have deep industry expertise and experience and should focus on short and sharp recommendations.
The bottom line is that if the management team knows what it is doing and is tight knit, they probably wont need to use consultants – they will intuitively know what to do and will just get on with it!
- When Times are Tough – Staff Need Transparency
Businesses around the world are going through tough times as the world's economy continues to struggle. In these tough times, business have to make tough decisions - often letting go of key people. In making these decisions, it is important...
- Tough Market Conditions Means Businesses Have to Get Real
Economic conditions aroun the world are tough. The question is now what is the likely impact on small businesses and more importantly those start ups that are reliant on funding to maintain their growth. To answer this question, I came...
- Going Global – Using Internal Consultants to Drive Productivity
Over the last little while i have written about how the REA Group expanded its business internationally in a series called Going Global. I have so far explored organic and acquisition based growth as well as the structure we put...
- Do You Really Need an HR Team?
I have been thinking about the role of HR in a business and a question that goes through my mind is "do you really need an HR team". Now i can hear the chorous of "of course you do" -...
- Why Do CEO’s Fail?
I recently wrote on what makes a great CEO. Well someone has asked “why do CEO’s fail?” I think you can look at this on three dimensions – structural, skill, and ego. Structural Some CEO’s are running businesses that are...
Recent Comments